top of page

Complex M&A Requires the Right Leadership

6 days ago
6 min read

For a company pursuing a growth strategy through M&A, leadership is critically important.  In this article, we examine in some detail four roles where quality leadership can significantly influence the outcome of a transaction.


Definition of Leadership

Though leadership can be defined many ways, for the purpose of this article, we will define it simply as the authority to make decisions paired with the accountability for the outcomes.  This document will argue that without alignment of these two factors, transactions tend to failure.


1) The Role of the CEO


For the CEO, there is clear authority.  And potentially clear accountability for the failure of a deal.  And unless the CEO is also the Executive Lead, there is a role in clearly delegating both the authority and accountability to the Executive Lead.


Either way, the CEO has the ultimate responsibility of setting / executing the overall strategy of the firm: making decisions about growth that will help expand opportunities, fill gaps and acquiring relevant resources.


But the CEO / Board show their value by guiding the company and continuing to rise above the day-to-day of the deal.  Asking the right questions about the direction of the target and considering how the acquired company will add value to the overall enterprise is critical.  Yes, EBITDA is important, but the Executive should have a broader and more long-term view than the baseline numbers.


Some common CEO / Strategy Errors that we have seen that lead to negative deal value include:

  • Engaging in transaction to “muddy the numbers” for a weak quarter / year

  • M&A for the sake of M&A – acquiring to get bigger without considering the fit or value

  • Pursuing M&A because having cash on the balance sheet begs implies that “something needs to be done”.  My mother called this money “burning a hole in my pocket”.

  • More of a Board Problem than a CEO problem, but with a similar outcome: making

    M&A completion (i.e. doing “x” deals per year) in the Performance Plan for the CEO.


CorpDev Consulting recommends the following best practices for CEOs:

  1. BEFORE starting an M&A process, ensure that there is alignment between ownership (Board) / Investment Committee and the CEO about the growth strategy for the company, including discussing the various vectors to growth (that may or may not involve M&A)

  2. To ensure alignment, engage the Operating Committee in the growth directions which allows the Executive Team to work together and hold each other accountable for a future go/no-go decision.

  3. If M&A is the chosen path (or one of the chosen paths), understand the required resources and provide them.  Create clear responsibilities and as needed bring in professional help to create structure and guide the overall process.

  4. If it is not the CEO, identify a clear deal team lead on the Executive team.  Someone with a “C” in their title with authority and accountability to be able to run the deal.  We’ll deal with this next….

 

2) The Role of the Executive Lead


Our experience points to the requirement than an Executive-Level leader will be identified as both having both the authority and accountability for the M&A transaction.  Sounds simple, but here’s where we break it down:


“Executive”:  Note that many organizations have individuals who are responsible for deals – usually Senior Corporate Development practitioners – but we recommend that having a clear single Executive eliminates ambiguities around shared responsibilities and matrices. 

Executive because they are completely read into the overall strategy of the organization with a direct line to the CEO and because of their overall visibility in the organization.

Executive because they understand how to manage the pressure and deadlines of mission-critical initiatives.  And hopefully because they understand broadly how the organization works and how to build support when needed.


Authority and Accountability:  The identified Executive must have the authority to bring resources quickly (immediately?) to the process, which is potentially more complicated than it appears.

 

CorpDev Consulting recommends that the designated Executive Lead has the following tools in their toolbox:

  1. The ability to make the preponderance of day-to-day decisions about the business without needing a ponderous consultation process.  This is different from organization to organization (and country to country), but in essence the responsible executive needs day-to-day authority over the transaction.

  2. The agreement of the other Executive Committee members and supported by the CEO to rapidly bring the right resources to the table without delay.  One phone call gets the resources.  Similarly, the Executive Lead is fully accountable to his/her peers in keeping them apprised of the progress of the deal.

  3. Complete authority over the deal team to prosecute the process as the situation presents.  Nothing about deals is standard, and internal politics can slow things at the wrong time.


Bottom line, one reason that companies skip this step is that “nobody wants the poisoned chalice”.  That, and “everyone is busy”.  But our experience has shown that delays in decision-making related to lack of authority often have a very direct correlation with poor deal performance.

 

3) The Role of the Deal Team Lead


Often the role of a Corporate Development professional, this is usually the key leadership role in the M&A process specifically.  And in general, while corporate-wide accountability is felt here, it is common for the Corporate Development team to have wide availability of resources to pursue the process.  That being said, there are a number of common failures that land on the desk of the Deal Team Lead.


Looking Up – In general, the Corp Dev team is well plugged into the Executive and often the Board.  They are trusted to understand the corporate strategy and in particular, the economic ins and outs of both the operating company and the outward-facing performance metrics.

Leadership skills here requires the ability to manage and motivate the Executive team, providing the appropriate information in a timely fashion in a language understandable to the stakeholders.  The most common failure looking up is being overly aligned with one Executive (typically the CFO).  The Corp Dev lead needs to be sensitive and aware to the resources of the various shared services in the organization.  This general awareness is important in effectively conducting due diligence and negotiating TSAs.


Looking Down – Deal Leads are frequently managing multiple priorities that focus on the closing of the deal.  But after the deal is signed, the work of planning for and implementing the acquisition becomes most important.  Leadership for the Deal Lead, assuming they are not the Post-Deal lead, involves ensuring the hand-off is efficient and effective.


But more than that, the Deal Lead is the main translator for the deal.  Beyond the assumptions, how do the companies combine to drive value.  The Deal Lead needs to ensure that the Integration Team understands the deal and the key levers for delivering value.

 

The Role of the Post-Deal Lead


The Post-Deal Lead is also usually known as the Integration Manager or Lead.  The typical skill-set includes strong cross-functional skills and knowledge, organizational skills (PM) and often some knowledge of the inner workings of the acquirer.


There are a number of flavors of leadership here beyond the obvious cross-functional team capabilities:

  • Helping lead the team through ambiguities of the deal paperwork

  • Identifying areas of value that the deal team missed

  • Using that IQ and EQ to help lead the acquired team to become part of the acquirer family.

  • Providing leadership / guidance to the PMO


Leadership Errors we typically see at this stage usually relate to misunderstanding the dynamics of the target.  Often described as “cultural”, some examples of misunderstood dynamics include:

  • Not understand the decision-making process (how decisions are made at target)

  • Not understanding the sales approach, particularly if it is different at the target

  • Getting the balance of deference and focus correct with target leaders (many of whom have just become wealthy)

  • Not understanding / not caring about why target companies do business with target (hint: it’s not all about price….)

 

Like other areas of business, leadership in a transaction is critical to mission success.  But the best results stem from having the right leaders, with the right alignment in the appropriate stage of the deal.


At CorpDev Consulting, we’ve helped to both provide and support leadership in a transaction.  Whether your organization could use experienced Corporate Development expertise to manage a transaction or help guide other leaders through the tricky waters

of deals, give us a call and let us help.  We’ve been there.

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page